So one of the big things I have been pushing for in my job has been VFDs on every motor >2 horsepower. VFDs can be incredibly useful tools. First of all, without considering energy implications, they give you finite control of the motor. Just being able to modulate capacity is huge, especially if you have a control system that can handle the input.
Energy savings, however, are really where its at. Most of our motors in the data center are connected to a fan or a pump. For the most part, fans and pumps are variable torque loads and (with the exception of some oddball positive displacement pumps) vary their consumption with the cube of the speed, per the fan laws.
In layman’s terms, if you slow a fan down by 20% (from 100% to 80%) you will only use about half of your original energy to turn the motor (80%*80%*80%=51.2%). So a 10 kW load will draw 5 kW at 80% speed. Even better, lets say you have 2 pieces of equipment (for redundancy in case one fails). Instead of having 1 of them off and the other on at 100%, you can run them both at 50% and achieve the same capacity (hydronic pumping systems have slightly different responses due to changes in other impacts, but the pump law will give you a reliable approximation).
With 2 motors at 50%, you are moving the same amount of air or water. Each motor, however, only uses (50%*50%*50%=12.5%) of its original power. Our 10 kW motor from before is now consuming 1.25 kW, and since we have 2 of them, we consume 2.5 kW of energy. That’s a quarter of energy to accomplish the same task. To put that in financial terms, that 7.5 kW of savings is worth between $3000 and $12,000 annually in energy (depending on how much you pay for your electrons). And what does it cost to make that happen? Well 2 15 horsepower VFDs will probably run you about $1000, and add another 500$ for labor and if you need a controller, another $500 should cover it. Sometimes, you may want to change out the motor, but in reality most motors are acceptable (per the MG-1 Nema Standard, class F or better insulation and a Service Factor of 1.15 or higher are acceptable, and it is recommended to de-rate the service factor to 1.00, limit the speed reduction to 2:1, use a low switching frequency, and keep your cable from the VFD to the motor short, but not shorter than about 24″). Remember, the guys telling you your existing motor isn’t good enough stand to more than double their bid if they include a motor replacement (a good, premium efficiency motor VFD rated with internal grounding could run 2500$ plus installation from your local shop). The VFD may shorten the motors life, so depending on the redundancy present and the criticality of the environment, peace of mind may be worth doubling the project cost. Even doubled, the paybacks are still fantastic.
And remember, if the fan is in a piece of cooling equipment, and it uses less power, it’s also generating less heat which adds a multiplier effect to your savings. So if the “mechanical” PUE is 1.5, and your saving 10 kW in motors, the net impact at your meter will be 15 kW (10*1.5). Say what!
This will be a frequent topic here, and as well will EC Plug Fans. Frequently used in data center “CRAC” and “CRAH” equipment, this equipment can do even better than VFDs, savings an additional 15-35% of your fan energy while moving the air in a more evenly distributed pattern, important for data centers looking to balance their air flow.